Cora Waterford knew Bellbird Bay had its small-town habits. The weather changed its mind without warning. Mrs. Pelham’s fortune stand sold more seashell charms than fortunes. And if Captain Sly the parrot started muttering secrets, somebody was about to have a very bad afternoon.
Cora found Mrs. Pelham on the pier, wrapped in her purple shawl and looking as if she had stepped out of a storybook and into a tea tin.
“You’re late,” Mrs. Pelham said.
“I closed the bakery first,” Cora replied. “Unlike some people, I cannot survive on gossip alone.”
Captain Sly ruffled his emerald feathers. “Gossip is breakfast.”
Cora laughed. “That bird needs a hobby.”
“He has one,” said Mrs. Pelham. “Announcing inconvenient truths.”
Captain Sly bobbed his head. “Treasure under the gull’s eye.”
Cora blinked. “Did he just say treasure?”
Mrs. Pelham pursed her lips. “He says many things. Most of them are theatrical.”
“Three keys,” Captain Sly went on. “One map. Don’t trust the one with the gold ring.”
That made Cora pause. “That sounded less theatrical.”
Mrs. Pelham gave her a long look. “Indeed.”
Before Cora could ask more, a man in a crisp tan coat approached the stand. He had polished shoes, a polished smile, and a gold ring that flashed whenever he moved his hand.
“Good afternoon,” he said. “I’m Mr. Alden. I run the new hotel on the bluff. I understand you have a very interesting bird.”
Captain Sly fluffed his feathers. “Gold ring. No trust.”
Mr. Alden laughed too quickly. “What a charming pet.”
“He is not a pet,” Mrs. Pelham said.
“Then perhaps an asset,” Alden said. “Guests adore local color. I’d like to borrow him for my lobby.”
Cora folded her arms. “Borrow a parrot from a woman who can read tea leaves and likely your soul? Brave man.”
Alden smiled. “I’m sure we can make it worth your while.”
Mrs. Pelham tilted her head. “I see a man with a locked door and very poor manners.”
“I see a fortune teller who enjoys drama,” Alden said, though his eyes sharpened. “Do take care. The cliffs are dangerous after dark.”
“Is that a warning?” Cora asked.
“It’s a suggestion,” Alden said, and walked away with the easy stride of someone used to getting his way.
Captain Sly leaned toward Cora and whispered, “Sneaky boots.”
Mrs. Pelham touched the bird’s beak. “Yes, dear. We noticed.”
That evening, Cora tried to focus on cinnamon rolls and apple tarts, but her mind kept flapping back to the parrot’s words. Three keys. One map. The gull’s eye. By sunset, curiosity had become a very persistent thing.
She locked the bakery, grabbed a flashlight, and took the cliff path above the sea. Wind tugged at her hair. The gulls wheeled overhead like scraps of moving paper. At the old lookout hut, she knelt beside a loose plank and found, tied in faded blue ribbon, three rusted brass keys.
“Well,” she said to the empty air, “that was almost too easy.”
A voice behind her said, “I was hoping you’d find them.”
Cora spun. Mrs. Pelham stood there, slightly breathless, with Captain Sly riding on her shoulder like a jeweled pirate.
“You followed me?”
“I prefer the phrase ‘kept pace,’” Mrs. Pelham said. “Captain Sly heard Alden and his men discussing the keys near the pier. He also overheard the bird part.”
Captain Sly preened. “Smart bird.”
Cora held up the keys. “So Alden really is after the treasure.”
“Not treasure,” Mrs. Pelham said. “History.”
Captain Sly fluttered down to a carved gull on the lookout post and pecked at it twice. Cora crouched beside him and found a tiny slot beneath the carving.
“Under the gull’s eye,” she murmured.
One key fit. Then another. A small hidden drawer popped open with a cheerful click, as if it had been waiting for its moment of glory.
Inside was an oilcloth packet.
Cora opened it carefully. “No jewels?”
“No jewels,” Mrs. Pelham said.
Only a map, a ledger, and a letter.
Cora read the first line and burst out laughing. “It’s a town fund.”
“The original founders hid it during a storm,” Mrs. Pelham said. “Along with records showing who contributed. Enough money to restore the pier, if handled properly.”
Captain Sly gave a pleased squawk. “I told you.”
“You certainly implied something,” Cora said.
A new voice cut through the wind. “How touching.”
Mr. Alden stood at the far end of the path, two men behind him. His smile was gone.
“I was hoping,” he said, “that bird would lead me here.”
Captain Sly puffed himself up. “No trust. No trust.”
Cora stepped back, tucking the papers against her chest. “You’re too late.”
Alden’s gaze flicked over the packet. “Those documents belong with the hotel investors.”
Mrs. Pelham sniffed. “Only if your investors enjoy harbor patrol.”
Alden frowned. “You wouldn’t.”
“I already did,” Mrs. Pelham said, smiling sweetly. “Captain Sly gave a very memorable statement.”
At that exact moment, the distant sound of footsteps and radios echoed up the path. The patrol arrived just in time to hear Captain Sly squawk, “Gold ring! No trust!”
The men with Alden stared at their shoes. Alden lost his color. And by the next morning, Bellbird Bay had its newest scandal, its oldest secret, and a very improved harbor restoration fund.
Cora stood on the pier with Mrs. Pelham and Captain Sly, watching the waves flash silver under the sun.
“So,” she said, “was he telling tales?”
Captain Sly blinked once. “Truth. With flair.”
Mrs. Pelham laughed. “I did tell you he was useful.”
Cora smiled. Bellbird Bay had not changed much. The weather still wobbled. The sea still glittered. And the fortune stand still sold more charms than fortunes.
But now everyone knew that if Captain Sly started muttering about gulls, keys, or suspicious men with gold rings, you listened.
Just in case the bird was telling the truth.
*****Amazon bestselling author Sharon Michaels loves writing cozy mysteries filled with mature characters, smart animals, and plenty of twists and turns.Her books are sweet, clean, and fun.
You can find fun books to read on this page:
https://sharonmichaelsauthor.com/cozy-fiction/
Copyright © 2026 – SharonMichaels.com – All Rights Reserved
